Inicio › Foros › Course Forums › Kabbalah in Action › Week 1 › Discuss › Ask anything about week 1 lesson and materials and get an answer from a senior Kabbalah instructor.
- This topic has 193 replies, 59 voices, and was last updated hace 6 meses, 1 semana by
Lorie.
- February 28, 2021 at 5:12 am EST #41560

Julian Edwards- KabU InstructorModeratorAsk anything about week 1 lesson and materials and get an answer from a senior Kabbalah instructor.
- Autor(a)Respuestas
- May 26, 2025 at 2:40 pm EDT #440106
Lorie
PartícipeIn this extract of “The nature of matter” it is written: “It is fair to say that we haven’t yet begun the process of know
ing the anti-Creator. To feel our complete oppositeness from the Creator, we will have to emotionally decline to much lower degrees. The wisdom of Kabbalah is surfacing now because it is impossible to experience these states physically, and Kabbalah is a means of easing our way through the states of oppositeness from the Creator, to experience them in our consciousness and our minds, not in our bodies.”I am intrigued by this notion. Does it means that we are not at the words of our egoistic behavior in this corporeal world yet? What does it means? I thought that Kabbalah was revealed nowdays because we reached the bottom of our egoistic desire?
Thank you much!
- May 26, 2025 at 7:05 pm EDT #440147
Gianni – KabU InstructorModeratorHi Lorie,
The ego is bigger than ever – that’s true. But it’s still at a tiny degree relative to the ego that has to stand against spiritual degrees. Yet this tiny ego is perfectly big enough to destroy most of humanity with nukes, hydro bombs and so on. If we reveal such near phases of its development corporeally, the handful who are left will have a life of such terrible suffering that they’ll have to correct themselves. Or, while the boot is still up in the air getting ready to kick us, we run ahead toward the spiritual goal. Either way, the end result is perfect, whole, and guaranteed.
- May 20, 2025 at 10:21 am EDT #439084
natPartícipeif everything is given by the creator, including the “evil” stuff, how can I counter act the evil stuff? doing good stuff?
- May 20, 2025 at 11:09 am EDT #439089
Gianni – KabU InstructorModeratorYes, but the only evil in the world is actions done without a spiritual intention. To ensure my actions don’t fall into that category, I need to develop spiritual intentions. Of course, in the meantime, as there is no usual definition here of evil, and I must co-exist with all the evil in the world, I don’t ‘turn the other cheek’ when someone hits me, but hit them back, and even hit them first if I see the punch coming. Since I’m behind on my inner correction, I have to deal with what could have been inner spiritual corrections – in the material of this world. About this, there’s already nothing to do but deal with it in the ways accepted generally by society. Going forward I will try to make more corrections internally, before those corrections come as corporeal matter.
- May 20, 2025 at 11:40 am EDT #439098
natPartícipeok so basically things of the Ceasar (wordly things) belong to the Ceasar and we have to deal with those in a worldly way. But those evil things came out of me because I didn’t implement spiritual intention. So the evil is an outcome of ungodly thoughts. am I following?
Recently I was sued unjustly, I have the option to fight but I kinda believe it came as a result of bad deed I did in the recent past (not related to this) so I assumed a bad deed of mine created a consequence, so I started doing good deeds to balance my past mistakes, I always believe only your good deeds will protect you. Is this the right approach according to the Kabbalah or I have to go back to the root of my thoughts/desires?
- This reply was modified hace 6 meses, 2 semanas by
nat.
- This reply was modified hace 6 meses, 2 semanas by
- May 20, 2025 at 1:18 pm EDT #439105
Gianni – KabU InstructorModeratorI’m assuming that what’s happening is for something I did. I’m assuming what I did was bad. I’m taking credit for something the Creator did with me. And I’m tying these false assumptions together into a model of how the world is governed. It’s exactly like I need to please Hapi or the Nile won’t flood or avoid black cats. It’s a kind of religion, but reality doesn’t work that way.
All the bad we feel is that we’re behind in our correction, so what could have been dealt with at a higher level, now I have to deal with according to the laws of this world, which are also the Creator’s laws, at the level of this world. Here, He has police, courts, world leaders, terrorists. I have to deal with them as they are, according to normal logic, without any imaginations about invisible forces.
- This reply was modified hace 6 meses, 2 semanas by
Gianni - KabU Instructor.
- This reply was modified hace 6 meses, 2 semanas by
- May 20, 2025 at 1:55 pm EDT #439113
natPartícipeok so how can I deal with this at a higher level?
- May 20, 2025 at 2:02 pm EDT #439116
Gianni – KabU InstructorModeratorYou can’t. It’s already reached the level of this world. You have to deal with it on the level of this world.
- April 13, 2025 at 11:26 am EDT #433181
ami
PartícipeDo the 4 phases of Light from Keter to Malchut also reflect in the path of the individual and their desires?
- April 13, 2025 at 10:27 pm EDT #433340
Gianni – KabU InstructorModeratorWe’re surely subject to this templates, as it spreads throughout reality like fractals, but we can’t in our state understand where we are in the process – like a small child that doesn’t know where they are in growing, though they’re growing tremendously.
- March 9, 2025 at 11:45 pm EDT #429007
Mike
PartícipeWow.
- February 13, 2025 at 6:28 pm EST #425951
LogynnPartícipeWhere it says that the creature shattered and all the pieces fused with all the individual desires contained in each one. . . is that like the idea of a holographic universe, where each unit within that universe is also a representation of the whole?
Is that how Arvut works, that as each universe (person) improves their image of reality, that they are all impacted?
- February 13, 2025 at 7:48 pm EST #425959
Gianni – KabU InstructorModeratorHi Logynn. Yes, that’s correct.
- January 11, 2025 at 1:24 am EST #415652
LukePartícipeAs we get into all things action related there is the system in kabbalah of roots and branches where I’m told everything that happens in the physical world reflects in the upper worlds.
I’m not Jewish but half of my family is and they constantly tell me that Mitzvot and covenants and prayer can’t be attained without the physical rituals in this world like Brit Milah praying from the siddur wearing teffilin etc so I don’t understand. Do these religious customs need to be performed physically in order to attain the spiritual meaning of them ? I can’t get a straight answer to these things and I’m still confused. The inner meaning I understand and I’m told that the Physical ACTION is the the action of the light on us and not customs or religious obligations that we do with our own hands. And also if these 2 worlds reflect one another in the branch system does that mean, war, arguments and sectarianism etc also exist in the upper worlds?. Everyday humans perform actions some good and some bad in this current era we can see so much awful actions being performed so do these actions good or bad exist in the upper world. ? As humans we have to make use of the Corporeal world but for the most part it seems kind of useless because in the end we will either be burried or cremated and then it’s all over for the physical body and it can’t perform anymore actions physically.- January 25, 2025 at 11:11 am EST #420318
Gianni – KabU InstructorModeratorHi Luke,
Sorry, there was some confusion on our end, I can answer. It’s true, Judaism is primarily practiced in a way that the main thing is to do actions from morning until night. It’s less about belief than other religions. You do all these actions, but do you also believe such and such? I suppose I believe that. But belief is not the main thing, in practice. And beyond believing, that I should also have specific intentions in my actions — let alone that the Upper World should open up… no one is even claiming such things, so I won’t upset anyone by saying that it won’t happen like that. The maximum claim is that in the next world (Olam HaBa) maybe it will be good for you if you do all the right actions — and in the religious lexicon that means after you die biologically. That’s religion. If it’s Judaism, the main thing is the actions; in other religions, it’s usually less about actions and more about belief. And in Kabbalah, neither will help.
Kabbalah is the hidden wisdom, the wisdom of intentions, which is why Kabbalists cleaned the language of all external wrappings. So, if you have such and such objects in the Upper World, maybe their mechanisms were expressed by something like you take the Tefillin and wrap in around your hand and so on, so Kabbalists since the 1500s started explaining that that’s talking about the actions of Zeir Anpin in the world of Atzilut, etc. All the physical Mitzvot (commandments) only come as a reminder that it is necessary to carry out internal acts of correction. If someone wants to do them, knows how, and will use them as reminders about the intentions, by all means, go ahead. He also needs to learn what the intentions are, but no one is stopping anyone from also doing their customs if they wish.
In short, here we learn the intentions that should be behind all our actions. And in general, we can go toward the spiritual goal like early Kabbalists, before the establishment of these “traditions,” which are behaviors in our world that are identical to the higher correction that everyone must perform in his 613 desires, aiming them at “love the other as yourself.” Achieve contact with the Upper World, like Abraham, for example, and then see if the Creator has anything else for you.
- This reply was modified hace 10 meses, 1 semana by
Gianni - KabU Instructor.
- This reply was modified hace 10 meses, 1 semana by
- January 12, 2025 at 2:12 pm EST #417310
Katrina LeeksPartícipeThat’s a really good question. I look forward to reading the response you get! I understood the performance of physical mitzvot as a performance of faith above reason. One can start the work without a proper intention. Yet, through the work one should come to the correct intention. I also see that we all have personal work to do. We all need to find and walk our middle line like Abraham and Jacob (find our connections, our ego, our scrutiny, and our faith above reason). I am 100% sure there are many more layers to both.
I feel drawn to want to know and understand the mitzvot. I also find it really intimidating, and my ego tells me I don’t belong.
- January 13, 2025 at 9:43 am EST #417417
Katrina LeeksPartícipeI’m so sorry to keep inserting myself. It’s like I’m stuck on your question.
Good and Bad, or the perception is only in the worlds BYA. I recommend reading the Introduction to the Book of Zohar. The Preface comes first, don’t skip it. He talks about keeping us focused on what we are able to learn in our current states. He explains levels of perception and shows them in relation to the world. After the Preface comes the Introduction. This is where he asks 5 common questions and answers them in depth. I’m not saying you will understand everything, but the more I learn the more the concepts come to life. You will get your answers if you keep going. The copy I have says Volume Two, and the original texts are from Baal HaSulam and the commentary is by Rav Michael Laitman PhD.
- January 12, 2025 at 2:30 pm EST #417316
Katrina LeeksPartícipeJust one more thought! We have to be in this world because it allows the Creator to be concealed from us. This is the only place we can actually do the work and achieve growth. Since this world is in concealment of course there are bad things happening. Our egos perpetuate the bad actions and also conceal the Creator. That’s why we work, so we can reveal the Creator step-by-step in this world. The more we draw the Light, the more we can add to this world.
- January 25, 2025 at 3:19 am EST #420288
LukePartícipeIt’s a question that never gets a clear answer and it’s hard to determine if what you have read and come to a conclusion to is what it’s supposed to be. I don’t think any instructor plans to answer this. Thanks for your input though. The moment I enter a 10 group I’m going to hit everyone with this question to see what the responses are 😆it’s burning my brain. I respect religious people but I cringe at the thought that I’d have to do rituals associated with religions to achieve corrections etc I’ve been religious before didn’t do anything for me. It’s an interesting topic.
- February 13, 2025 at 6:15 pm EST #425947
LogynnPartícipeI was raised in a Science of Mind church, which reads from the texts of every religion. They have Jesus, Buddha, Native American deities and Krishna on the same mural in the sanctuary. We celebrate Kwanza, Eid al-Adha, Naw Ruz… everything.
So, it might be easier for me to approach the concept that rituals are only tools for cleaving to your spirituality. My family is from that church also, and one who attends is an atheist who considers it to be similar to TED talks. And this is accommodated by the church, in that they try to word things to be non-specific and only to talk about the concepts. Even the traditional prayers have all reference to specific names and genders removed. And they try not to refer to God as a being unless we are celebrating a holiday taken specifically from one religion.
It actually works really well. Last I checked 6,000 people go to that church.
That being said. In my adult life I have found it much easier to have rituals. Because of my background I had no issues picking and choosing the ones that serve me. My goal is to imbue my mundane life and routine with reminders of the Creator. In my case this is most effective with principles of Ayurveda and Vastu (from Hinduism.) I only chose these because they pertain to everyday things, and they address everything. You can get so granular that there are specific ways to breathe, ways to eat, ways to sleep, ways to bathe, ways to pee… everything! And they also have a mantra for every occasion.
This means that everything in my life has a meaning attached to it that reminds me of the Creator, and by doing it in that specific way I can acknowledge the Creator. I can arrange my house by these rules. I can even sleep that way, by having a mantra in my head that I know so well that my brain continues it when I’m sleeping and I’m already thinking about the Creator before I’m aware that I’m awake in the morning.
Regardless of what the “mitzva” is… I think this is the point of rituals. Not everyone knows this is the point. And I think this is why the Kabbalists don’t outright dismiss them. They are only about the interior, and only about the intention… BUT, doing the action can help you be intentional. So, the answer to “do you have to do the rituals” is yes AND no.
- May 26, 2025 at 3:07 pm EDT #440107
Lorie
PartícipeLoggyn,
I find your comment and explanation of religion ritual really interesting. Also I did not know that a religious movement such as “the Science of Mind Church” existed! I also think that any ritual is highly personnal and good so far as it helps you, soothe you, gives you strenght, etc. on your path and have a signification for you (I mean any person). For example, a ritual of honoring the dead help you processing you grief and so on.
- February 13, 2025 at 6:20 pm EST #425948
LogynnPartícipeI was just thinking I should mention that the way I came to this method of the Hindu rituals is that I had horrible anxiety and hyper vigilance. I noticed over time that the trigger seemed to be feeling like I wasn’t doing what I was supposed to be doing. (Probably a side effect of overly strict parenting by extended family.)
So I started all this simply so I could feel, in every moment, like I’m doing what I’m supposed to. And I could stop worrying about it.
Someone from a religious background probably feels the opposite anxiety, and might have to think of it differently.
- Autor(a)Respuestas
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

