- This topic has 1,042 replies, 416 voices, and was last updated 2 days, 3 hours ago by
.
- Replies
Seth,
You write in your reply to Kim:
“… we were created 100% opposite from the Creator. He is 100% to give and we are 100% to receive.
But, this also leads to another problem. Due to this situation, we our qualities are opposite from His and we are as far as east is from west.
And so through many garments called worlds, the Creator clothes Himself more and more until all that remains is a tiny spark of light that shines through. This is what we grab onto and slowly by working, dancing, playing with Him, we reveal more and more light until we do reach again that state of complete unity with Him”My question is why didn’t The Creator create us complete from the beginning? The fact that we cannot do or create anything or everything tells us that logically The Creator can create anything and everything. So why all the climbing and searching? Why not being in complete equivalence of form with Him to begin with?
If I may attempt an answer myself: Is it again that we cannot comprehend the answer while at the level I am at now? Is it that I have to do the climbing and learning first, and then later I will understand?
In other words, I will just have to follow my intuition since at this point I will not be able to see for myself what the truth is in any scientific or empirical sense, kind of like a baby has to trust his parents’ guidance. Am I right, or have I completely misunderstood this?
Thank you so much in advance.
PS. If my question is too incoherent to answer, I understand.
Jack,
Let’s say you inherited 20 million dollars.
But let’s say you didn’t know about it. And you go to work, and you take care of life and you are worth 20 million dollars, but, you don’t know about it.
Then one day someone comes to your door and explains that a long lost uncle left you all of this money and it is yours to do whatever you want with.
So the 20 million was yours before, but you didn’t know.
So let’s say that is us with the Creator now. He is here, revealed in all of His glory, but I don’t see it, I don’t feel it like that, not because of Him, but because of my awareness.Now let’s understand another scenario. Imagine that one is totally adhered to the Creator in every thought and feeling, every smallest detail is in absolute harmonious synchronization with the thought of the Creator. Well in that scenario, the person ceases to exist, he is totally nullified before the Creator, totally absorbed, like a spark is indistinguishable inside of the sun.
Now we can understand why there is the concealment, so that we would not remain nullified and opposite from the Creator, but that we would go through a special process whereby we would be separated and then by traversing the distance between Him and me, I come to know Him, understand Him, feel Him, arrive to be with Him in unity.
Seth@KabUSeth,
I understand perfectly now. Thank you for taking the time to explain. – Isn’t it funny how sometimes you can battle with a question for days or weeks (in some cases even years), and then when you realize you have to ask the question, and you muster the courage to do so, and somebody with a kind heart and the necessary knowledge answers, the answer suddenly becomes clear as if a thick fog had lifted. and you have to wonder how there was ever a time when you didn’t understand the problem?
You have such a beautiful way with words, it’s a pleasure to read your reply posts also to other students.
Thanks again………Jack.
I think the purpose is that we prove our desire to be like him, he wants us to deny our selfish desires to prove that we truly desire what he wants for us and not just our selfish desires. There is evil among us and there is a thief that steals for greed i.e. The bank robber and the thief that takes food so as not to starve. This is food we must seek out of necessity rather than selfish wants. If one does not need than one does not want. The paradox of the wisdom of truth is such that if one does not think than one can be connected to the source, but can one survive without thought or knowledge? I think yes and this should be our goal, be still and know that I am God. Like the Indians that would sit and sit because they were afraid that the slightest movement could cause something bad to happen. Just my opinion
This infinite pleasure that the creature was meant to enjoy. Is it pleasure as we know it like laughter, fun, good food, good friends, be able to share with others, giving to those who have needs, not lacking anything or is it a state of contentment with where you are and the fact that you are alive and you know what lies beyond this physical world.
Bolevia,
In the same way that a child cannot understand the pleasure that a grandparent receives from gazing upon her grandchildren, similarly from our state we cannot relate to a pleasure that is on a degree above us.
Think of the pleasures of a cat which is on the animate level and your pleasures on the human level, now imagine that from spirituality which is above our degree compared to our degree.
The difference is that the gap between us and the spiritual is greater than the gap between the cat and us.
Seth@KabU
are so called “visions” or as we call them dreams and having a certain if not total understanding of it a sixth sense? An understanding of something one does not necessarily know the full of the matter? If that makes sense
Enoon,
Dreams are something different than the sixth sense.
Here is a blog post by our teacher the kabbalist Rav Laitman where he explains dreams:
https://laitman.com/2015/01/the-origin-of-dreams/#gsc.tab=0
Enjoy,
Seth@KabU
i have learned our five senses block us from perceiving the truth, it is what makes the water mercy. what runs me is called my egoistic desires. which is needed but should be corrected.
i need to see things through the eye of my heart and mind, not the physical. i need to connect to the spiritual. as long as i stay in the mindset to desire to receive pleasure only for the self, i will not grow and connect to the creator, myself or his creation.
we need to correct our will to receive to become also as the creator are, a bestower.we need to learn to call out:”let there be light from our own darkness”.
Why has the Creator arranged things in this way, that we the Creatures would be separated and need to find our way back to the Creator? I’ve heard a number of theories on this, ranging from the Fall of Man (we started out as perfect and in harmony with the Creator but then fell from grace, now existing in this separated state of limited physicality), to the notion that the Creator is fun-loving and simply playing a grand, cosmic game of hide-and-seek with Itself, having iterated itself (blown itself?) into trillions of pieces which It then must find Itself through each piece as each piece comes back to together.
What do Kabbalists believe? Thank you SO MUCH!!Kim,
We limit the books that we study from to only books written by kabbalists who have reached the spiritual degrees that they are writing about.
We have major works like the Study of the Ten Sefirot by Baal HaSulam, which itself expands on the Tree of Life by the ARI. These texts describe how the light of Ein sof emanates from above to below and cascades down through the worlds, partzufim and sefirot.
Additionally we have texts that deal with our inner work from the opposite direction, from below to above. Where we study all of the degrees that we go up as we retrace the steps that the light took as it was concealed and came down until our world.
But your question is clear, and demands and answer, why all of this system in the first place?!
And here we have a simple answer, however it takes time and effort to understand.
The kabbalists explain that we are still in the field of endless light, love and bestowal. However we don’t feel it, we feel the opposite, that we are always deficient, empty and far from the Creator.
They explain that in the state where we are totally absorbed and one with the Creator, with the endless fulfillment, there in that place we don’t feel ourself at all. The Light is so great, the pleasure so great that we lose all sense of self and are totally absorbed. To give you a much smaller example, image if your biggest role model of all time were to come to you and ask to spend the day with you. Could be the person you admire and hold the highest in your eyes and this person wants to spend the day with you. So you would be happy to carry his or her bag, to eat where she wants to eat, to talk about what she wants to talk about, you wouldn’t care about your own needs because you just want to be with this other person. Now image that it’s not another person, but the source of all life, in this case, our identity is like a spark absorbed in the sun.
So how do we solve this problem? How can we feel all of the abundance and love?
For this we were created 100% opposite from the Creator. He is 100% to give and we are 100% to receive.
But, this also leads to another problem. Due to this situation, we our qualities are opposite from His and we are as far as east is from west.
And so through many garments called worlds, the Creator clothes Himself more and more until all that remains is a tiny spark of light that shines through. This is what we grab onto and slowly by working, dancing, playing with Him, we reveal more and more light until we do reach again that state of complete unity with Him, but now it will be after all of our efforts to reach it, so instead of being a spark absorbed in the sun, we will be fully conscious and have attained all of these sensations and feel that we are together with Him in everything, eternally.
Seth@KabIThis is the clearest and most perfect answer I’ve ever gotten. Thank you so much. Is it fair to say, then, that from a kabbalistic point of view, there is no such thing as true sin? For example, suppose we are thought to be living “a sinful life” from a mainstream religious point of view. Is it correct to say that a kabbalist would disagree, believing instead that we are simply exploring and learning as we make our way through “deep and dark” places that are very different from spiritual Light, on our journey back home to the place of spiritual perfection? Or, put another way, perhaps we’re playing out a role in a grand, cosmic drama that requires certain things to happen in order for other things to come into being as part of the unraveling of time and space–here in ordinary 3-D–of the perfection that already Exists? I’ve heard it said that God doesn’t care a whit about what cosmic games we like to play, or what kind of roles we like to enact throughout our various lives. Being raised with some heavy Catholic guilt, however, I find the idea of a Creator who is 100% loving and giving both an incredibly hopeful, yet hard to trust, notion. I want to believe it, though, and I also realize that some things just have to be experienced–which is why I’m here! 🙂 Thank you again!
Kim,
The most perfect answer ever!
I’ll try to keep up the quality of work here.
Regarding all of the baggage that you are bringing from previous places… first of all, have some gratitude for all that prepared you for where you are now and the path you are on. Second, you will have to work with this and if you want to advance, you will need to get past it.
A person who still speaks like he did in 5th grade will not succeed as a lawyer.
Similarly, all of the definitions and concepts that you grew up will not help you in a new place with new definitions.
What is a sin?
What is love?
Who are Adam and Eve?
What is day and night?
What is the exodus from Egypt?
For a kabbalist, all of these things are inner states that each person will go through.Instead of answering, what is a sin in kabbalah? first you need to know what is this wisdom you found and how does it depict reality, what words do the kabbalists use and if they say sin, what do they mean? When they say Israel & the 70 nations of the world, they are talking only about the different desires in each and every person.
So, follow the lessons and try to grasp what we are learning. If things are not clear, write down notes in your notebook.
And importantly, do not apply definitions from another place to what you hear in the wisdom of kabbalah.
It will confuse you a lot and you will not be able to move forward naturally.
Seth@KabUThank you so much, Seth! I’m so grateful for your replies. Please tell me if I’m on the right track. I’m now understanding this as akin to enlightenment, where we finally realize that these dichotomies of “good and evil” are merely illusions of living in our “will to receive” state. As we draw closer and in greater alignment with the “will to bestow” state of the Creator, such dichotomies will disappear. In its place, it will become self-evident what the true unifying Thought is behind everything. (Is that right?)
This is such an amazing and comforting thought, that nothing “bad” really ever happens to us, that there’s no devil or evil adversary out there. Events in life are just all part of the corrective process to get us back Home! Behind everything is our Creator’s intense love and desire for us. Mind blown!
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.